Skip to content

LETTER: County's new trash bins called 'industrial-sized' solution to 'residential' problem

'Perhaps some thought should be given to the entire plan, for which it appears the main concern is cost,' Collingwood resident says of new curbside collection bins
2020-11-24 NewBins JO-001
Samples of the new bins that would be procured for use in homes across Simcoe County starting in Nov. 2021 are pictured on the right. County councillors voted to obtain black bins with green, blue and black lids (for organics, recycling and garbage respectfully) in order to save on costs. Contributed image

BarrieToday welcomes letters to the editor at Please include your daytime phone number and address (for verification of authorship, not publication). The following is in response to stories titled 'Garbage collection days changing in parts of Simcoe County' published on July 27, and 'County expects to roll out new waste carts between August, October' published on July 28. 

I would like to write on behalf of my mother, who lives alone in a house in Collingwood.

Her driveway is adequate to contain and roll down these bins to the edge of her road. Her driveway is only about 50 feet long.

So what it’s the problem, you ask? My mom is 98 years old. She eats sparingly and makes little garbage on her diet of veggies, meat, potatoes, bread, soup, tea and milk. She puts her garbage out every other collection day, and then the bag is only half full.

Even with the waste of doggie bags from her faithful Aussie shepherd dog, she doesn’t come close to filling the green bin. At most, she fills a single compost bag per week.

The blue recycle bag goes out once a month, too.

And how is a 98-year-old going to get these bins to the road in winter?

They will have to be rolled out by myself on Sunday night and we will hope that they do not get buried by a snowfall before morning.

My only thought is that we could approach her neighbours and ask if she could piggyback her refuse with their contributions each week.

Perhaps the county could entertain the idea of ‘neighbourhood bins’ in areas of single people where the residents could pool their garbage.

We live close to my mother  not next door, but across town in Collingwood.

A third alternative may be that we incorporate her garbage with ours, and perhaps that is the best and most obvious solution. OK for us.

But what about all the other elderly, incapacitated people in Simcoe County.

Surely our situation is not unique.

We are an adult family of three with two cats and even we cannot envisage the need for these huge bins unless they are being picked up monthly. It feels like an industrial-sized solution to a very urban/residential problem.

Perhaps some thought should be given to the entire plan, for which it appears the main concern is cost, ie., the number of people needed to effectively collect our garbage.

So when all the people who presently collect our refuse are laid off, how does that balance with the outgoing EI and welfare payment that may result?

Just a question?

Paulette Dennis